Best Dog Shock Collar - Comparison and Reviews

Becky - author

Author: Becky Roberts
Last Updated: October 2019​

If you’ve ever been at your wit’s end trying to train your dog to obey and behave, you may want to consider investing in a dog shock collar. The idea is not as painful as it sounds anymore, thanks to humane technology.

Dog with Collar TagDog shock collars today offer a variety of ways to help train your dog. Many shock collars also make a beep sound at a frequency that will discourage your dog from barking. Other collars include a light and vibration setting. The vibration is unpleasant but harmless and helps get your dog’s attention.

You don’t want to hurt your dog, but you don’t want your dog getting hurt or hurting someone else either. It’s okay to try a dog shock collar. We’ve reviewed the top ten for you, all with great ratings and features to help you train your dog safely.

Best Dog Shock Collar 2019 - Reviews

1. Dog Care Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar

Loving your dog but not his behavior? Is training not going so well? This rechargeable shock collar could make all the difference in your peace of mind and your dog’s obedience!

It’s waterproof, and you don’t have to start with the shock. First try the beep or vibration training modes, at the lowest intensity and see how your dog responds. Go slow. This collar fits any size dog, and you can use the remote to train up to nine dogs at the same time!

You can charge the receiver and transmitter, and both of them have excellent battery life. The remote will switch off after 20 minutes in idle mode, to save battery power. Don’t worry about accidental shocks. The remote has a built-in security keypad to prevent that. Invest in a training tool that is safe, gentle, and won’t hurt your dog.

Dog Training Collar - Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar w/3 Training Modes, Beep, Vibration and Shock, 100% Waterproof Training Collar, Up to 1000Ft Remote Range, 0~99 Shock Levels Dog Training Set

Pros

  • Offers three training modes – beep, vibration and shock
  • Includes a security keypad lock to prevent accidental shocks
  • You can train up to 9 dogs with one remote
  • Fits any size dog
  • The intensity of training modes ranges between 0-99
  • Control your dog up to 330 yards away
  • Rechargeable transmitter and receiver – the receiver’s power lasts 15 days, and the remote’s power lasts up to 45 days
  • Receiver is waterproof

Cons

  • Only in black
  • May cause skin irritation if unchecked

2. TBI Pro New 2019 Dog Training Collar with remote

If you want to get results in training your dog, this collar is an excellent product for puppies and adult dogs. This high-quality rechargeable dog shock collar is durable and waterproof.

The remote control is comfortable to use and has an impressive control range of up to 1,500 feet. This range is 30% more than most shock collars. Choose between four modes — beep, light, vibration, or shock. You can turn the intensity up from 1-100, all without hurting your dog.

Make sure it’s turned off before you adjust the fit on your dog’s neck. You should be able to fit two fingers between the collar and your dog’s neck, so it shouldn’t be super tight. The receiver ought to be on his neck, close to the ears. Start on the lowest settings to see how your dog responds. If your dog is uncomfortable, take it off. Do not leave it on for more than 12 hours at a time, and check the skin for signs of irritation. Enjoy training your dog successfully!

TBI Pro Dog Training Collar with Remote, Long Range 1600', Shock, Vibration Control, Rechargeable & Ipx7 Waterproof, for Small, Medium, Large Dogs, All Breeds

Pros

  • Durable and waterproof collar and battery
  • Provides control over a 30% longer range than most shock
  • collars – up to 1500 feet
  • User-friendly remote control with intensity settings of 1-100
  • Rechargeable, lithium battery charges in 3 hours and lasts up to 20 days
  • One-year replacement guarantee
    Four modes: beep, light, vibration, and shock

Cons

  • Only in black

3. Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar

A dog-training collar that comes in six different colors; this neat set is suitable for small and medium dogs weighing 5 pounds and up. The remote looks like a stopwatch. It is very discreet and easy to use.

The idea is not to train your dog by scaring them, but rather to provide enough stimulation to discourage bad behavior. The Educator E-collar gives the dog a strong tapping sensation, like a vibration, but more effective. You can set the stimulation to the level that works for your dog (start at the lowest level). Lock it in so that you don’t shock him accidentally. Your dog will be safely trained in no time with this tool.

Educator ET-300 Mini 1/2 Mile E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar With Vibration, Tapping Sensation and Pavlovian Stimulation

Pros

  • Available in 6 colors – purple, black, upland orange, waterfowl camo, yellow and zen
  • Small receiver suited to small and medium dogs
  • Small, ergonomic transmitter for discreet usage
  • Gives the dog a tapping sensation that’s more effective than a vibration
  • The intensity of stimulation ranges from 1-100, and there’s an extra booster that ranges from 1-60
  • The collar has two points of contact
  • Long-lasting rechargeable lithium batteries

Cons

  • Expensive for a collar that has limited training features
  • One-dog system
  • Short control range – half a mile

4. Pet Union PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training Shock Collar

The Pet Union shock collar is quite popular, fully waterproof, and very tough. If your dog is obstinate, he has met his match here. The collar offers four modes of training: a light for nighttime training, beep, vibration, and (only for emergencies) shock. You can adjust the vibration and shock levels between 1-100.

Choose from 7 tasteful colors. If there is any malfunction or damage, the product has a lifetime replacement warranty. Take your dog outside with peace of mind, knowing you can control the dog from up to 1,200 feet away. An effective training tool at an affordable price, you won’t regret trying it out.

Pet Union PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training Shock Collar, Fully Waterproof, 1200ft Range

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Waterproof
  • Offers four modes of training – beep, light, adjustable vibration, and shock (1-100)
  • Long-lasting lithium battery with built-in power-saving mode
  • Comes in 7 colors – black, charcoal, orange, green, light gray, red and yellow
  • Long control range of up to 1,200 feet
  • Lifetime replacement warranty

Cons

  • The shock setting is only for emergencies
  • No locking feature to prevent accidental shocks

5. TBI Pro 2019 Heavy Duty Dog Shock Training Collar with Remote

One of the most impressive dog shock training collars on our list, the TBI-Pro collar boasts a control range of up to 2,000 feet. For once, you’ll be able to control your dog without having to run a marathon if he takes off!

Fully waterproof, the collar fits any size dog. The controller is large and easy to use with separate buttons. Choose from three training modes – beep, vibration, and small shocks. Use the shock setting only in an emergency. The beep and vibration should be enough to train most dogs, and you can adjust the strength from 1-100.

You can charge the receiver and the remote at the same time within about 2-3 hours. Remember not to leave the collar on for more than 12 hours at a time and check the dog’s skin for pressure sores or irritation. At night, you can use the handy light feature on the remote. Get equipped to train your dog safely, easily and quickly with a great collar.

TBI Pro Dog Shock Training Collar with Remote, Heavy-Duty, Long Range 2000 ft, Rechargeable, IPX7 Waterproof, E-Collar Shock Collar for Dogs Small, Medium, Large Size, All Breeds

Pros

  • Moderate cost
  • Fits any size dog
  • Extensive control range of up to 2,000 feet!
  • Large, handy controller with separate buttons for easy use
  • Offers three training modes – beep, vibration, and small shocks
  • Long-lasting rechargeable lithium battery
  • Waterproof
  • Free replacement warranty

Cons

  • Not available in multiple colors
  • No locking feature to prevent accidental shocks

6. SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers

If you’re a fan of training hunting dogs or field dogs, this collar may well be the perfect choice for you. A simple but efficient setup, it’s got all the essential features. Training your dog doesn’t have to be an ordeal for him or for you.

Choose between three training settings – beep, vibration, or shock. The shock setting offers up to 21 levels of static stimulation. The beep and vibration settings should be enough to train your dog. You can probably reserve the static stimulation for emergencies.

The collar and remote charge within about two hours and battery life will last up to an impressive 70 hours. Control your dog at a maximum range of 500 yards, with a remote that is easy to use even in your pocket. This will help you train your dog with consistency and excellent timing.

SportDOG Brand Family Remote Trainers

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Long-lasting rechargeable lithium batteries
  • Offers three modes of training – beep, vibration and adjustable hock (21 levels of static stimulation)
  • Fits medium to large size dogs
  • Remote can control up to 3 dogs at the same time (via extra collars)
  • The company offers a 1-year replacement warranty plus customer care support
  • Good control range of up to 500 yards

Cons

  • Does not fit small dogs
  • Expensive

7. Petrainer’s Dog Shock Collar

Looking for something much more affordable? Petrainer’s dog shock collar is cheap but still comes with all the basic features you need. The transmitter and collar are waterproof, and the collar has three training settings – beep, vibration, and shock.

When training your dog, start with the simplest settings and go from there. The shock setting you can adjust from 1-100 depending on how your dog responds. The product fits almost any size dog and comes with an extended 3-year warranty. With a control range of around 330 yards, you can train your dog safely and easily.

Get your dog’s barking, chewing, digging, and biting behaviors under control in a humane way. Soon, you’ll enjoy a more obedient dog, and your dog will surely get more reward treats!

Dog Shock Collar - Remote Dog Training Collars with 3 Correction Training Modes, Shock, Vibration, Beep, Rechargeable Waterproof E-Collar for Dogs Small, Medium, Large, 1000 ft Remote Trainer Range

Pros

  • Cheap
  • Offers three types of training settings – beep, vibration, and adjustable shock (from 1-100).
  • Easy to use
  • Suitable for dogs of any size
  • Transmitter and collar are waterproof
  • Free 3-year warranty

Cons

  • No locking feature to prevent accidental shocks
  • Control range of only 330 yards
  • Only comes in black

8. Ipets PET619S Dog Shock Collar

The Ipets dog shock collar is suitable for dogs of any size. If you struggle to train your dog to stop aggressive behavior, excessive barking, biting or digging, this collar could be the answer.

The simple design offers beeps, vibration, and shock (adjustable from 0-100). There is a separate button for each mode, allowing for quick and easy training appropriate to your dog’s behavior and response. The system is waterproof, so if you’re the type to train in all kinds of weather, don’t worry.

The remote can control two separate dog collars at the same time (though only one is included). The contact points on the collar are made of conductive plastic for extra safety. As a bonus, after registering your product, you can get an extended warranty for three years.

Ipets PET619S 100% Waterproof & Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar 900 ft Remote Dog Training Collar with Beep Vibrating Electric Shock Collar Dogs (10-100lbs)

Pros

  • 1-year warranty, extended to 3 years if you register your product after purchase
  • Completely waterproof
  • Rechargeable, long-lasting lithium battery
  • Easy-to-use design
  • Offers three training settings – beep, vibration, and shock, adjustable from 0-100
  • Affordable
  • Suitable for most dogs
  • Safe plastic contact points

Cons

  • Control range of up to 220 yards, which is less than some other products reviewed here

9. Nemobub Dog Shock Collar

This dog collar comes in a comfy silicone sleeve for comfort. Its other capabilities include the standard training modes of beeping, vibration, and adjustable shock. The intensity of the stimulation ranges from 1-100. We recommend only using the shock setting for emergencies.

Most dogs respond very well to the beep or vibration. The collar is waterproof, so no need to worry if your pooch is a swimmer. The remote control has a practical design with a separate button for each training mode. The collar fits on any size dog. Just be sure to position the prongs on the neck and check it every couple of hours. The collar comes with long shock nuts for large dogs and short ones for smaller dogs.

Now you can get your dog to be calm, well-behaved and obedient, without hurting him or stressing him out. Having a dog should be enjoyable, and this training tool helps make it possible.

Nemobub Dog Shock Collar 1600ft Remote Training and 100% Waterproof Rechargeable Shock Collar with Beep Vibration and Electric Dog Collar Dogs

Pros

  • Offers three training modes – beep, vibration and shock adjustable from 1-100
  • Separate button for each training mode for easy use
  • Waterproof
  • Rubber oil surface on the collar for comfort
  • Control range of up to 330 yards
  • Suitable for small, medium and large dogs
  • Long-lasting rechargeable lithium batteries

Cons

  • No locking feature to prevent accidental shocks
  • Moderately expensive for standard features
  • Cannot control more than one dog at a time

10. BOIFUN Advanced Dog Training Collar

Meet your new dog training friend, the BOIFUN advanced collar. This company has your dog’s best interests at heart. BOIFUN’s collar has an automatic 4-second static cut-off to make sure your dog is not harmed by a prolonged shock. It also has a lock button on the side of the remote.

You can train up to 9 dogs with one remote, so it’s useful if you are a professional dog trainer working with many dogs at the same time. The standard training modes of beep and vibration are enough in most cases, and the shock mode is adjustable from 0-99.

With this tool, you have top-notch help right in your hands. Teach your dog to bury their bad behaviors and understand your commands using a safe and waterproof collar. Remember to reward your dog’s obedient behavior with treats and praise!

Advanced Dog Training Collar W/Remote for Small Medium Large Dogs, 3 Training Mode, Beep, Vibration and Shock, Waterproof Rechargeable Dog Training Set, 1000foot Remote Range, 0~99 Shock Levels

Pros

  • The automatic 4-second static cut-off prevents prolonged stimulus
  • A lock button on the side of the remote prevents accidental shocks
  • Control up to 9 dogs with one remote
  • Offers three training modes – beep, vibration and shock (adjustable from 0-99)
  • Long-lasting rechargeable lithium battery with power-saving mode, with a standby time of 40 days (and a visible monitor for battery level)
  • Affordable
  • Waterproof
  • Control range of up to 330 yards
  • 2-year warranty

Cons

  • Do not use on aggressive dogs
  • Only comes in black

How to Choose the Best Shock Collar for Your Dog

There are so many shock collars available today; it can be overwhelming to choose. Some collars have a remote that can control many dogs at the same time. Most collars have multiple variable settings.

amstaff pitbull

Others have an extensive control range for field dogs and more. To help with your decision, we’ve listed some important features to look for when buying a shock collar. After all, your pooch deserves only the best and safest training tool.

What features to look for in a dog shock collar

  • Light, tone, vibration, and shock signals – light settings are useful for training at night. The tone-setting will make a beep at a harmless frequency that will encourage the dog to respond to your command. Vibration mode will provide a little more stimulation than the beep. Shock signals are usually adjustable, so you should only need a low setting in an emergency to control your dog.
  • Range – most shock collar remotes have a control range anywhere from 200-400 yards. This allows your dog to roam freely, but you are still able to control him in training.
  • Waterproofing – this is crucial! You don’t want your dog ruining the expensive collar with one splash in the pool.
  • Remote control – the remote control should be easy to use, with buttons that don’t get stuck. Choose one with a locking feature that prevents accidental shocks to your dog.
  • The number of dogs you can control per remote – if you need to train more than one dog, look for a shock collar with a remote that has multiple channels. This will allow you to control more dogs if you buy extra collars.
  • Battery types – most dog shock collars have rechargeable lithium batteries with a power-saving mode. Check reviews to check how long they last. The average battery life is typically about a week.

FAQs

Are e-collars and shock collars the same?

Essentially, yes. There is a difference in connotation, though. Shock collars are thought to actually shock the dog. E-collars (short for electronic collars) don’t shock the dog but provide stimulation like that of a physiotherapist’s “stim” pad. It doesn’t hurt, and it actually helps the dog learn to understand which behaviors are unwanted. E-collar is the modern term because development in technology has improved its safety in dog training.

Do shock collars hurt a dog?

Shock collars are far better today than years ago. Developments in technology mean that these collars are much safer and more humane to use. They come with safety features to help prevent accidental shocks or prolonged stimulation.

The collars can hurt a dog if left on for over 12 hours. It can cause sores and skin irritation, so be sure to check often.

Are shock collars good for training dogs?

Shock collars can be very helpful tools when used correctly in obedience training. When giving your dog a command, first wait to see whether the dog responds. If he doesn’t, repeat the command and add a beep stimulus. If your dog responds to that, reward him. Try the collar out on the dog by starting with the lowest beep and vibration settings. See how your dog responds before you slowly turn it up. Usually, shock stimulation is only used in emergencies.

Can a shock collar make a dog more aggressive?

When a shock collar malfunctions or is used inappropriately, yes. If the settings are too high, the anxiety and stress may make the dog respond aggressively. If you have already tried training your dog with a shock collar according to instructions and used positive reinforcement without success, get professional help from a behavioral expert.

When should a shock collar not be used?

Never use a shock collar on a small puppy, a sick or injured dog, or an aggressive dog. In the case of puppies, train them using normal commands and positive reinforcement.

How old should a dog be to use a shock collar?

Puppies are still learning about the world around them and need time to adjust. It is not recommended to use a shock collar on a puppy, except in exceptional cases. Use your own discretion and try other positive training methods first. If major problems persist, try using one after the dog is a few months old.

Safety tips for using a shock collar on your dog

Here’s a guide on do’s and don’ts when using a shock collar:

  • As mentioned before, never leave a shock collar on your dog for longer than 12 hours.
  • Check your dog’s skin often for irritation or sores and wipe clean with a damp cloth.
  • If the shock collar seems to be malfunctioning, take it off immediately. Contact your supplier to arrange a replacement.
  • Before using a shock collar, first, train your dog to be familiar with general commands. This will avoid confusion and unnecessary stress on your dog if you do actually decide to use a shock collar later.
  • Remember that the collar is only intended to be an extra training tool. It is not a magic bullet. As the pet owner, train your dog with positive reinforcement so that your dog feels secure and confident in the process.
  • Give your command first, and then if your dog does not obey, use a beep or vibration stimulus as secondary reinforcement. When your dog obeys, reward him.
  • Readjust the collar on your dog’s neck every couple of hours, to be sure the stimulation is properly directed and in the correct position.
  • The shock collar should fit securely on your dog’s neck, but not too tightly. You should be able to get two fingers between the collar and the dog’s skin at any point.
  • Choose a collar with a lock setting for extra safety.
  • Never attach a lead to a shock collar. Use a separate normal collar or harness for attaching to a lead.
  • Only use the collar when you are actively training your dog. Don’t leave your dog alone with it on and assume that automatic stimulation will do the trick. Ultimately, you are the trainer, not the collar.
  • Use the shock collar as a training tool only for as long as it’s necessary. Most dog parents report fast results, so the idea is not to use it long-term.

As seen above, shock collars are not as cruel as they used to be. The idea is not to punish and hurt a dog to get cooperation but to deter the dog from unwanted behaviors with an uncomfortable sensation. When used properly, along with other positive dog training methods, it can be very effective and help you get a great outcome. It’s up to you to choose – and there are plenty of good options to choose from!

Scroll to Top